Notes for
Humanities 100
2/02/2012--Good
morning. I was asked "...what suggestions you have
to being a successful student in your class?" the
link to How It Works on
the first page of
www.casad.com helps here. Let me go further
though. Review all the links, read, and write
online. Open a web screen and a writing file at
the same time. Learn to move back and forth
between web and writing file. Cut and paste as notes but
do not copy unless you quote the source. Take the
notes and develop your own copy. Stay on task for
an hour or two...more if you are fit for it. For
the course as a whole, work to the end, do not give up,
finish with the world view and extra credit. To be
successful you must finish. Improvement counts.
1/25/2012--Good
afternoon. As defined in the syllabus, I do not
mark or return late or incorrectly submitted homework.
If the work is late but correctly submitted, I check to
see if it is complete, file it, and respond to the
student that the homework is on file. This all needs to
take place within a few days of the homework assignment
due date.
1/23/2012--Good
morning. Be sure to turn in at least the first two
weeks of homework by midnight tonight if you have not
had Internet Service.
1/13/2012--Good
morning. As you do your homework, write to one
file for each assignment due date. The first file,
yourlastname1.doc or .rtf contains all of the homework
for weeks 1-3. Proofread and edit your homework.
Have a great day and weekend.
1/4/2012--Good morning and welcome to Humanities
100. I (your instructor Dr. Casad) will respond to
your emails this afternoon. I look forward to
hearing from you all and wish you a successful quarter
and a happy new year.
Welcome Winter 2012
students. The notes below contain
guidelines and examples to clarify many questions you might have. Be sure to
read them at least once a week and before you turn in your homework. The
notes often repeat instructions given in other pages. Some of you may need to scroll right to find
the writing assignment links in the Course Guide. There is an
example first assignment in the Course Guide under Assignments. Write about what you think, not about what you
think others think or should do. When you work on your assignments and are developing
your responses, be sure to provide specific, concrete examples. Use
"For example," or "e.g.," (example given). Avoid using "you" second
person; use "I" first person. This advice is especially true of the
relevant quotes (to the week's topic) from resources. Follow the assignment instructions for format
and content. Always try to improve--Never discourage
anyone who continually makes progress, no matter how slow-----Plato.
General Note
Put Humanities 100 in the subject line of all your
emails.
Please use formal email format when you
check in and submit
assignments, e.g.,
Hi Dr. Casad, (Salutation with comma)
My first set of assignments is attached. I look forward
to your response. (standard capitalization and punctuation)
Regards, (Thanks, Sincerely, Regards, etc.) (Complementary close with
comma)
First and Last Name

Again, welcome to the Humanities 100
Internet class. If you have looked at the course guide and assignment examples,
you will know by now that each week's assignment comes in three sections-- read
and respond to the readings (quickly summarize the reading assignment, quote
from the reading, and describe your reactions); respond to the writing task; and
select and comment on a quote from resources. To get full points for the
quote from resources, you need to explain the relevance of the quote to the
week's topic.
When I receive your attached homework file,
I open the document, read it, make comments,
assign points, save it, and then reattach it to an email reply to your email. Be
sure to fill in the subject line of your email, e.g., Humanities 100. Do not send a folder (send a file). If you cannot properly attach a file, you
will loose points or receive no points at all since I will not be able to read and mark
your material. I do not accept late work unless you have made arrangements beforehand (usually you would just send the work in before
the due date).
Here are some more tips for getting started:
 | Read the syllabus and read the notes throughout the quarter. |
 | Establish your personal email account. |
 | Learn to save, attach, and send files
.rtf or .doc. |
 | Use a computer and the Internet for most of your course work. |
 | Remember that a week's work is
worth 10 points. Stay on task; as an independent learner, you know your
typical errors. Do your homework
when you like and as much as you like, as long as you are responding
to the assignments and making every word count. |
 | And, of course, follow the course guide. |
I look forward to a great class and
some insightful writing.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The notes below contain
examples and advice from previous quarters. Check them weekly. There is a wealth of information in the previous
notes, so please take some time to read them. You can use
the notes to post relevant questions to the class after the second week of the
quarter.
Go
to Course Guide
Student Note on Getting Started Thanks
Milan.
This class consists of 11 weeks of work (done in 8 weeks during summer).
These 11 weeks are divided into 5 sets of assignments. There is one week
in the first set of assignments, three weeks each in the second, third fourth sets and a final extra credit assignment. Every week (except
for Week 10) has a reading assignment, a writing assignment and
a quote from resources. Every week (except for the very last week, which is
extra credit) has 10 possible points. This way you can get up to 104 points if
you do the extra credit (4 points), but you need at least 97 points for a 4.0
grade.
In
the reading assignment you are supposed to read the given material, summarize
and quote from it, reflect on it, and answer any questions from the directions. Since
some reading assignments are difficult to understand, try analyzing them by
reading topic sentences of paragraphs and trying to understand the main point.
Then you can decide which part is the most interesting, so you can spend some
more time summarizing that part. For doing this correctly you can get up to 3
points.
Your second task has 4 possible points. The writing assignment is usually
totally different from the reading assignment. It may even include separate
reading or analyzing. If you find the writing hard, you should always go back
and re-read the instructions. Also you should read the Notes link for extra
help. If you are still confused the best thing to do is email Dr. Casad with
your questions.
After you have done this, you should go to the resources link on the website and
find a quote from any one of the resource files. This quote is supposed to have
something to do with the week's topic. For a quote relevant to
the Week's topic from one of the resource files (Author and File Number) and an
explanation of why you chose that quote, you will get 3 points.
If
you read the instructions properly, have time to do your assignments, and turn
in your work on time, you should have no problems in getting a good grade in
this class, and as my old science teacher would say: “Good luck, even though
luck has nothing to do with it.”
Week One
When you do your homework, imagine that your
audience wants to know your thoughts about how you think and act, not what
and how you think others think and should act. It may be best for some of you to
avoid the second person point of view (you), or at least reserve it for
instruction and standard procedures.
You do not need a book. Lay out your work. Schedule time each week
for reading and writing. Have fun, but keep yourself on schedule. If you
devote ten hours a week to computer reading and writing
at the web site, the
only hitch might be that you may want to spend more time on some parts.
Don't let writing style throw you off. Scan. Keep a vocabulary list. Check
for new notes at least once a week and before an assignment is due. I may
put extra credit in the notes (but only a few points).
Spend 10 or so hours (break into
smaller units) on the computer at the web site to get started. You must be able to get the assignments from the web site.
Avoid using old copy of the website.
Divide your weekly work into sections:
reading response, writing/task response, and quote response. Remember to
put your work into a file, e.g.,
smith1.rtf or doc.
Be sure to quote the main thesis/idea in the reading
assignments to get maximum points. Also, when you are explaining the
relevance of your quote from resources, make sure it is not a platitude or
overgeneralization by explaining the conditions under which it is not true.
Go to Resources at the Humanities 100 website. Find a quote from any one
of the folders that is relevant to the week's topic and which you fancy.
So if the topic is "learning to think," find a quote that relates to thinking
(has the word think in it?). Then make sense of the quote. Is it more true
than not? Under what conditions is it not true? Is it a witticism
that is meant to be funny? Do your best.
Do not forget to send a standard email when you attach your file (salutation, message, close).
Your entries include a response to the reading, a response to the weekly
writing task (varies), and a quote from resources. So, each week will have three entries.
Class procedures/grading--I will put
the weekly points immediately under the relevant section in the assignments, with a
maximum 3 points going to your response to the reading, 4 points going to the
task/writing assignment, and 3 points going to the quote each week. For those
students who are still having some difficulty, do not give up! Don't miss
the whole point of creative and critical thinking--success!
Class procedures-- By now you will have
read examples at this site. In some cases the examples are only partial
answers or hints. They do not spare you from doing your own reflecting and
extended reading. Please follow a consistent format each week. For
clarity, you could use the headings-- Reading Assignment, Writing assignment, Quote from Resources. Do not forget to chose a relevant quote, explain why
it is relevant (if not obvious), and explain the circumstances wherein the quote
may not be true (so that you develop the habit of questioning truisms and over
generalizations). Remember to spell check, grammar check, edit, and
proofread your writing (and this includes the salutation, short message, and
close in the email).
Class procedures--I do not accept late work unless you have made
arrangements beforehand (usually you would just send the work in before
the due date).
Class procedures--If you are not using Word, save
and send your files (rich text
format, abbreviated rtf.)
Quotes--I have posted a new page, analyzing
claims. Take a
look and apply this map to analyzing your quotes.
Class procedures--if you just print off
only some of the pages,
you are going to miss the hyperlinks. Plan to spend time hitting all the
links. Visit the site frequently. Please follow correct email procedures. Hi/my
name; short message; regards (or some complimentary close/your name. Do this even when attaching a
file.
Grade Scale: Over the course of the quarter, you can accumulate 100
points not counting extra credit. The points will produce a decimal grade like this: 106-97(4.0),
96(3.9), 95(3.8), 94(3.7), 93(3.6), 92(3.5), 91(3.4), 90(3.3), 89(3.2), 88(3.1),
87(3.0), 86(2.9) ...57(0.0).
Week
2
When you have scanned and read "The Tragedy of the
Commons", put in your homework a description of the tragedy in your own
words--hint (a combination of two principles--personal right to procreate and
moral obligation to help the less fortunate).
Reading Assignments-- Not
only comment on the reading assignment but directly quote at least once.
Also, when you choose a quote from resources, not only indicate its relevance
(if not obvious) but also describe a condition under which the claim may not be
true. Finally, maintain an introspective point of view and tone.
Write about how you think, not about how you think others should think.
Rob's sixth rule: Pick up after yourself.
Every fool can make a rule and every fool will mind
it.-----Henry Thoreau
(Does Henry define the set of fools'
rules? Unless one defines the character of the set, then the statement
simply says, fools mind their rules. I guess this implies that wise
men neither make rules nor mind them...?)
Week
3
Remember
that when you are looking through the Project Zero web site, you are interested
in the Theory of Multiple Intelligences, but that need not limit your
surfing. Be sure to find, read, and reflect on "Seven Steps" by
Howard Gardner.
Week 4
Jackie Eppler-Clark
UNDERSTANDING SELF/OTHERS
Week 4: Reading Assignment
07/08/00
Maslow popularized psychological humanism, the belief that human
behavior is directed by both physiological needs (air, food, water) and
psychological wants (living up to ones fullest individual potential). Maslows
hierarchy of needs expresses the theory that some motives are more instinct
driven, more compelling and basic, than others and only if these basic needs for
air, food, and water are met are we able to move up the pyramid to meet our need
for safety, belongingness and love, and esteem needs, to the highest level,
self-actualization needs.
To learn what was necessary for positive mental health, Maslow
approached the issue from a different angle than earlier psychologists in that
he chose to study healthy, creative people rather than those with "broken
brains." Subjects of his research included Abraham Lincoln and Eleanor
Roosevelt. Both had positive characteristics, such as high values, a sense of
purpose (self-actualization), and werent fearful of others opinions.
Maslows hierarchy of needs follows a logical progression of a
human lifecycle. An individual is born with the basic, immediate need to satisfy
air, food, and water. As the infant begins to develop, the first basic need is
still there, however, the need to feel that the world is organized and
predictable comes into play, as well as the need to feel safe, secure, and
stable. When the need for safety has been satisfied, the need to love and be
loved, to belong and be accepted, and to avoid loneliness and alienation are the
driving needs. Only when these three fundamental needs are satisfied can an
individual move on to the next level of the need for self-esteem, achievement,
competence, independence, and the need for recognition and respect. Living up to
ones fullest and individual potential meet the highest level on Maslows
pyramid, self-actualization needs.
Although all mankind have these primary needs, cultures approach
the esteem and self-actualization needs from different viewpoints, thus
influencing their world view. Ive become aware of the societal difference in
the importance of self through my international student hosting involvement and
it has given me much pause for reflection in on or about? the different
self-esteem values various cultures nurture. The Canadian and European students
exhibit contentment with their esteem needs by focusing on their personal goals,
attributes, and achievements. On the other hand, Chinese and Japanese students
are raised in a more collective society that places high value on the goals,
attributes, and achievements of the group rather than the individual.
Each of these differences influences a cultures self-esteem
and I can see benefits to both sides. Students coming from an individualistic
culture place value on personal independence, their identity, and their personal
achievements. The students from a collective society gain their identity from
belonging to a group, the groups goals/solidarity, and their we"
approach to social responsibility. Even with the differing values that cultures
place on what comprises self-esteem, these needs must be met for a positive
self-concept, happiness, and success.
It is much simpler to do the course assignments if one reads the
previous notes. Interpersonal consistency and self knowledge maintained their
positions as the overall most sought characteristics in others (and self).
Be sure to document all of your
sources. When you quote from a reading (or any other composition including
these notes), be sure to indicate the primary source and how to find it
(including Internet urls).
If you do not indicate the source of your quote or paraphrase, you will not
receive credit for the assignment. This includes the file reference in
your quote from resources (e.g., Resource File 5) the course guide, and material
in the notes. Consult a college English handbook to get the
documentation and format right. Proofread and edit carefully since you lose points for rough compositions.
I do not accept late work, so be sure to send your homework correctly by the due
date.
Week 5
Occam's Razor 2011: When comparing two
or more more explanations (theories) with equal predictive capacity and
explanatory power, focus on the one that makes the fewest assumptions (givens, tested
claims or claims which are not falsifiable). For example, some
explanations for crop circles require assumptions of space travelers, or druidic
magic, while others only assume tractors and pranksters.
You will need to find and use current statistics
to do and get credit for the Week 5 task. Be within +/- 5 million for world population. Use the US Census Bureau for current US
Population.
Simplify, but not too much. This is an Internet class so I expect you to
do the research and find the data on the net. What I want you to do is to
make some true and valid inferences about the human condition using the facts
about growth in population and energy production and consumption. This
does not entail discussion of greater efficiencies which is part of an
administrative, congressional, and environmental debate now.
Week 5--
Looks like World population hit 7
billion by the end of October 2011. It was 6 billion when I wrote the Week 5
assignment 12 years ago. "It took 250,000 years to reach 1 billion, around
1800; over a century to reach 2 billion (in 1927); and 32 years more to reach 3
billion. But the rise from 5 billion (in 1987) to 6 billion took only 12
years." "A Tale of Three Islands," The Economist, October 22nd-28th
2011, pages 28-30. The same article reports that North American fertility
rates are 2.03, Latin America 2.30, Europe 1.53, Africa 4.64, Asia 2.03,and
Oceana (Australia/Indonesia) 2.49. A fertility rate slightly over 2
(2.1) will maintain the current population. The low fertility rate
countries (Europe and Japan) will have a significant demographic problem by 2050
when there will be almost as many dependants (young and old) as working age
adults and put much strain on pensions and health care which rely on tax
revenues from a working population. For 2 points extra credit, what is the
predicted population for 2050 (name your source).
Here is a student product on consumption and
available resources from 1999. Notice the change in population since.
Still, world population is increasing at a decreasing rate and world production
(the pie) is growing at least up to the great recession. Be sure to use
current population when you do your calculation.
From 1999:
Current world energy production 382.18 quads BTU (Use
400)
Current US energy consumption 94.79 quads BTU (Use
100)
Current US population 274,297,970 (Use 275)
Current world population 6,046,196,184 (Use 6.1),
then
400/100 times 275 equals 1.1 billion--about 5 billion
short of the mark.
Number of people able to be supported = 382.18 quads/94.79
quads x 274,297,970 = 1.106 billion people
Some other facts of interest--
If present population growth, domestic food
consumption and topsoil loss trends continue, the U.S. will most likely cease to
be a food exporter by approximately 2025 because food grown in the U.S. will be
needed for domestic purposes. The groundwater that provides 31% of the water
used in agriculture is being depleted up to 160% faster than its recharge rate.
Even if water management is substantially improved, the projected 520 million
Americans in 2050 would have about 700 gallons/day/capita, considered the
minimum for all human needs, including agriculture.
On a per acre basis the United States now has 1.8
acres (1999) of cropland resource per capita to provide Americans with an ample diet of
plant and animal products. The average American consumes about 2,175 pounds of
food per person per year. Americans currently use about 1,450 gallons/day/capita
(g/d/c) of water for all their needs. Hydrologists consider 700 g/d/c minimal
for human needs, including water for adequate food production. 1,300 gallons of
water, 1.8 acres of arable land, 2.3 acres of pasture land and 2.2 acres of
forest land is available per a person per a year.
Estimates
are that about 20% of U.S. land area (about 450 million acres) would be required
to support a solar energy system that would supply but one-half (37 quads BTUs) of
our current energy consumption (80 quads BTUs). This land requirement can be expected
to diminish arable, pasture, and forest lands to some extent, with the most
critical loss being arable land.
Thanks Brandon (1999)
Week
6 I have selected the Emerson essay to read. Follow the link in the
course guide--an excerpt from "Self Reliance." All students
will read the same essay. Be sure to give me your take on the main
ideas of the essay.
The egalitarian fallacy is a term coined by Barbara Herrnstein Smith to critique the
notion that "relativism" implies all opinions are equally valid. In
her 1998 book, Belief & Resistance, she describes it as
follows: "much of the sense of intellectual and moral scandal
evoked by the charge of "relativism" derives from a supposed
implication . . . that, according to the skeptical or unorthodox
doctrine in question, everything-every opinion, every scientific
theory, every artwork, every social practice, and so on- is
'just as good' as every other
I call this general supposition and argument the Egalitarian
Fallacy. It is a fallacy because, if someone rejects the notion
of validity in the classic (objectivist) sense, what follows is not
that she thinks all theories (and so on) are equally valid but
that she thinks no theory (and so on) is valid in the classic
sense. The non sequitur here is the product of the common
and commonly unshakable conviction that differences of
"better" and "worse" must be objective or could not
otherwise be measured. When appealed to in the argument
the conviction is obviously question-begging" (77-78).
If you have read the above (the fallacy)
mention so in your Week 6 homework.
UNDERSTANDING PARADIGMS
Week 6: Writing Assignment
07/15/00--(A student's response to the assignment) The paradigm of traditional classroom-based education has taken
a dramatic shift in the past few years with the growing popularity of the
Internet. In the fall of 1997, 6,065 students took distance learning courses in
Washington community colleges. By the fall of 1999 that number had almost
doubled to 12,000 students. (And what do you think the number is for
2006?--rc) But, as with most transformations from one model to
another, there are both pros and cons in this new education method.
The convenience of learning without time and place restrictions
is one of the driving forces behind the success of this paradigm shift in
education. Without the requirement of attending classes at a specific location
at a specific time, Internet classes now provide an opportunity for the
non-traditional student to earn college credits.
No longer is a student forced to select a college near home.
With more Internet colleges and classes coming online at a rapid pace, students
arent limited to an institution that is physically located in their area.
Internet education vastly broadens the choice of where to participate in
classes. Also, from a colleges standpoint, their database of students could
include learners from anywhere in the world.
However, to be successful in Internet-based education, a student
must be motivated and interested. I personally dont consider this as a con,
but to the student who cant work independently, Internet education isnt a
viable option. (This is becoming more true as students opt for the
convenience without good computer reading and writing skills--rc.) Learning
outside the traditional classroom setting can be difficult for students who
cannot think and work on their own or are not self-motivated. Just as in the
in-class setting, an Internet learner must have the self-discipline to commit to
setting and maintaining a schedule that allows for keeping pace with the class.
The highest cost I see with Internet education is the lack of
social interaction. Social skills and relationships are not developed in
Internet education to the same degree as with the traditional face-to-face
in-class learning atmosphere. Students rarely, if ever, personally meet their
classmates or the instructor. Although I prefer to take online classes because
they fit into my work and personal schedule, I do miss the social interaction
that takes place in the traditional on-campus classroom.
Week 7--I hope this note will clear up some confusion about myth.
Thrall, Hibbard, and Holman in their A Handbook to Literature make the
following distinction:
Myth in its traditional sense is an anonymous,
non-literary, essentially religious formulation of the cosmic view of a people who approach
its formulations not as representations of truth but as truth itself; myth
in the sophisticated literary sense in which it is currently used is the intelligible
and often self-conscious use of such primitive methods to express something
deeply felt by the individual artist which will, he hopes, prove to have
universal responses.
When we approach literature as myth, or examine literature through myth, we
look for a framework that embodies the general beliefs of a culture, social
class, or nation; a cosmic view (like in Blake or T. S. Eliot); or some set
of unconscious values. We look to see if and how the poet or writer
touches something deeply felt with a power akin to the traditional anonymous
myths.
Let's go one step further. Let's say that
advertisers are myth makers (or myth reinforcers) when they promote one can of
peas over another can of peas or one make of SUV over another make of SUV. The modern myth
is that there is a positive relationship between the object's dollar cost and the
object's utility, namely the more you pay the more (of something) you get.
This simply is not true for canned peas and what you get with SUV's is more
maintenance costs, higher insurance costs, and higher fuel costs. So what
is the advertiser to do. Touch them deeply. Dig into the unconscious
values and beliefs of the consumer-- strength, vigor, social status, sexual
readiness (dancing babe/Pepsi/Dole/dog).
Many students are confusing fictions
with myths. Authors create fictions. Cultures create myths (a least
in the traditional sense). Fictions are, but are not. Myths are not, but
are. Myths are part of a belief structure and often not connected to facts.
Fictions are fact based or reality based (verisimilitude) or you would not
understand the characters or the story line. We believe myths; we suspend
disbelief for fictions. Hope this helps.
Thanks
to Katie Perman for the Week 7 example below.
Week 7, Reading assignment
Words
are very powerful. We may use a
word to conjure up many images, themes, feelings, or ideas.
However, we are often unaware of the true meaning of the words we use, or
what they may imply. Because of
certain words, phrases, and ideas that have been repeated to us through our
lives we may not think twice when someone says Dont go outside with wet
hair or youll catch a cold. We
believe these myths and take them as common knowledge.
It is not so hard to detect the myths when someone from another culture
is around. Then it may be difficult
to explain just why wet hair and outside lead to a cold. Of course, it gets even more complicated when it comes to
explaining our cultural myths regarding religion, choice, independence, or
morals.
Advertising
and mass media seem to recognize our cultural myths and use them manipulatively.
Since we may not recognize the myths or the meanings they imply, they can
unconsciously influence us. I am
the first to admit that I do not stop to think about the strange images in
commercials or slogans in magazine ads. I
have the tendency to take things at face value until something is pointed out to
me. I am guessing that is how most
people are, and that is why mass media can strongly influence us on an
unconscious level.
Myths
can be perpetuated in ways that affect our culture negatively.
Certain racial and cultural stereotypes fill our televisions, newspapers,
and magazines. For instance, a Nike
commercial in 1996 in New York stated, "The revolution is about basketball,
and basketball is truth." It
showed young African American men playing basketball, as if to say because some
African American men can play basketball well, a revolution to end oppression
has begun. Displaying
basketball--and of course basketball shoes--as a "truth" or
"God." Obviously, this is
blurring and oversimplifying the big picture issues of racial discrimination and
oppression. However, it may speak
to the unconscious of the viewer, appearing as though if only they would buy
some Nike basketball shoes and play basketball they would be making a
difference, joining the revolution.
Speaking
of Nike, it was interesting for me to find out the meaning of the word Nike.
Nike is the Greek personification of victory; another image and word that
has infiltrated our society without many realizing its mythological
significance.
I also
read about the Greek characters Narcissus and Aphrodite.
Narcissus was an attractive man and many nymphs and girls fell in love
with him. After he rejected so
many, there was a curse put on him that he would fall in love with his own
reflection. He stayed staring at
his own reflection until he died. The
word narcissist or narcissistic is used commonly today to imply someone who is
entirely focused on him/herself. The
myth of Aphrodite, the goddess of love, beauty, and sexual rapture, also still
exists in our culture today. She
had a festival called the Aphrodisiac. We
commonly use the word aphrodisiac today as a type of food or anything that may
get us in the mood for sex. Her
symbols were the dolphin, the dove and the swan.
This is interesting because we see doves and swans at weddings (expensive
weddings), symbolizing beauty, purity and love.
In Roman mythology Venus is the goddess of love and Cupid is the
messenger of love. Of course, we
still see the funny looking Cupid every Valentine's Day, and we hear it in
songs, "Cupid, draw back your bow, and let your arrow go
."
Again, many people do not know the origination of so many of these
mythological figures and words.
Week
7, Task assignment
I
recently watched "What Dreams May Come."
I thought it was a phenomenal film that brought up many important
questions, and alternative answers. It
went against the common myth that Heaven and Hell are definite, solid places
like Earth. Also, it went against
the idea that Heaven and Hell are the same for everyone. It did, however, contain mythological ideas about family,
work, and love. Along with that, it
presented mythological themes about courage, endurance, regret, personal
strength, and dreams.
As a
collective American society we tend to believe that the perfect,
"normal" family is a mother, a bread-winning father, a little girl, a
little boy, and a dog. That is the
family presented in "What Dreams May Come."
The father is demanding and rather distant, spending most of his time
with work. The mother is giving,
loving, and nurturing. The movie
explores the pain and heartache of death as first the children die, then the
father dies, and finally the mother kills herself.
It implies that the main thing that matters in life (and death) is
family. It also brings up the
concept of soul mates, a widespread belief our society seems to hold.
It attempts to explain the existence of soul mates and the extreme power
soul mates have on each other's lives. He
has the courage to go to Hell to see his wife and try to be with her again.
He was willing to give up his Heaven because Hell with her would be
better than Heaven without her.
In life
and death, a major theme the father constantly reiterates is "Never ever
give up." I think this is
another mythological theme we see as an important truth. At least in my family, it was engrained in me to never give
up. Throughout life I have heard
that if you give up you wont be able to reach your dreams, success takes
determination and persistence.
The
father also experiences regret, for all the pressure he put on his son.
He wishes they could have been closer.
I think one common regret in our society is the way people have raised
their children. Ive heard
parents say they were too strict, too selfish, they didnt spend enough time
with their children, they were too demanding, they used their kids.
Parents often deeply regret the way they have or have not influenced
their children.
And
finally, the father demonstrated ultimate trust in love.
He trusted that his love for his wife would bring her out of Hell so they
could be back together again. The
saying Love conquers all has been repeated to me throughout life.
Now of course it seems hard to believe that love conquers all when you
look at the divorce rates, the abuse, and the infidelity in our culture. Still,
I believe in it because it is a myth I have been taught and it helps me sleep at
night. This ideological belief was
played out in the movie, conveying the idea that in life and death love does
conquer all.
Week 7, Quote
A lie
told often enough becomes the truth.
-----Vladimir
Lenin
It seems that myths
are generated so freely, and repeated in so many ways that they become a truth,
a reality. That can be quite
devastating if it is a hurtful myth. It
is also destructive when a lie becomes the truth because it becomes so hard to
reverse the damage.
To get full points on the quotes from resources,
explain whether the quote is a truism, and, if not, under what condition(s) it
may not be true. For an extra credit point, go to writing resources at
Casad.org and then to skepdic.com and pick the pragmatic fallacy under logic and
perception and summarize what pragmatic fallacy means. Put this at the end of
Week 7 under the heading Extra Credit.
02/18/07--Here's a response to a student about the reading
assignment in Week 7 and whether one can use a fable:
You can find myths in fables. Fables are fictions meant to tell
a moral truth. Myths are not fables unless the moral of the/a fable has
become a group's cultural/ethnic explanation of creation, hope, life, death, and
chance. Myths are peoples' beliefs in explanations of events they did/do not
understand or could/can not explicate/replicate. Morals are lessons in values
and virtues. Knowledge turns myth to fiction through experience and analysis.
Heroes searching...life unfolding.... We don't believe fictions but we do
believe in heroes and purpose in life. Many people believe a variety of myths.
Write about one of your favorites in the writing task, but be sure to describe
one you find in the reading assignment and point to what it explains.
03/4/08--Myths
are not truth based as are fictions. Myths are belief based, as fictions are
not. We do not believe the movie as fact (we suspend disbelief). We do believe
good conquers evil, however untrue given cultural conceptions of what
constitutes good and evil.
Week 8
Reading Assignment
In your next journal submissions, please make clear references to
the reading assignments. You can copy and paste a short passage that you
like into your journal document. I know that the Mill essay is long and
sometimes difficult, but find something in it, some insight, that is memorable
and useful to your thinking. This goes for the other reading assignments
as well. Also, choose quotes that are relevant to the week's topic.
Clear reference and relevance are worth as much as two out of the ten weekly
points. Finally, some of you may be losing a point each week on English
grammar, usage, spelling, and punctuation errors. Be careful. Check
your work twice before you send.
Writing Assignment Sample
I found some literature on the web that talks about how Evolutionary
Psychology involves psychological adaptations that are universal among humans.
The goal of Evolutionary Psychology, then, is to discover and describe
the functioning of our psychological adaptations, which are the mechanisms that
cause our behavior. Evolutionary Psychologists argue that our psychological
adaptations cannot possibly be designed for modern life because this complex
adaptation is a very slow process, typically requiring hundreds of thousands of
years. Instead, they must be
designed to solve the adaptive problems faced by our hunter-gatherer ancestors.
Throughout history, human cognition has undergone
selective adaptation. Skills and
values that were important during the time of hunter-gatherers survived, while
other non-useful elements were weeded out.
So, in essence we can assume that the qualities of human nature that we
possess today must have held some importance in the distant past.
The next step is to identify those tendencies, and determine what purpose
they served at that time, and how to best use them now.
One example of an emotion I see in my life that
remains from the cave man days is a certain resentment I have towards
attractive women. I consider myself
to be a nice-looking girl, so I shouldnt harbor ill will towards other pretty
females. However, so often I find
myself scowling at the vivacious gorgeous blonde who walks by.
I think that this results from the competition that was involved with
finding a mate. I need to be ready to be the first to jump at a good male
prospect, and prepared with certain hostility to defend myself should push come
to shove (or scratching or pulling hair).
Integrity is important to survival because survival
is easier when you are in a group. If
you are consistently honest and sincere, and your actions coincide with your
moral convictions, then others will trust you and stick by your side.
On the same token, humans need to be able to detect who is trustworthy in
order to protect themselves from being tricked or taken advantage of.
For this purpose, I think humans have the skills to detect fakes or
scams. However, I feel that this
skill has diminished somewhat over time as other elements of our world have been
introduced (police, lawsuits) that provide more cushion.
We no longer have such a fine-tuned instinct, like the wild animal that
can sense fear in its prey.
It is true that humans are homeostatic in nature,
maintaining stability and equilibrium in the social aspect of their lives.
Anytime we step outside this zone of homeostasis we create stress.
So why are we so fascinated with the extremes of the world? Why are there hundreds of magazines devoted to exploiting the
lives of big celebrities, who in no way represent the average person?
I believe that it is part of human nature to be fascinated with seemingly
unattainable things. I dont believe that I will ever be a movie star, and I may
not want to be, but I cant avoid the fact that the movie star life fascinates
me. At the same time, the news is
always informing us about the horrible conditions of poverty-stricken people in
poor countries. Humans need to have
people with which to compare their lives. Most
people realize that the big and fabulous isnt the norm, so they dont
expect their lives to ever be that way. They
can also be thankful that there is always someone who is worse off than they
are. As C. H. Spurgeon said, It
is not how much we have, but how much we enjoy that makes happiness.
Somehow they realize that where they are is the best place to be.
Week 9
Be sure to read Virtue Ethics carefully so that you can define the difference
between virtue and a rule bound morality to get full points.
As to virtue, here is a bit from Chaucer's Prologue to the Canterbury
Tales, "A knight there was and such a worthy man that from the time he
first began to ride out he loved chivalry, truth, honor, and courtesy."
Week 10
You do not need a quote
from resources for Week 10.
Here is an interesting article on the survival value of beliefs: http://www.csicop.org/si/2000-11/beliefs.html Do not use second person point of view in the world view statement
and try not to preach. (But if you must say what ought to be, save it for
the last few lines.)
You may put all of your work (World View, Self Assessment, and
Site Assessment) in the 4th file, e.g., smith4.doc or smith4.rtf.
Otherwise you may send the self and site assessment extra credit separately
(smith5) as shown on the course guide. Describe the progress you have made in your self assessment.
Use the 30 thoughts under "Beginning Thoughts" on the first page of
the website.
Science and technology can not define the nature of good and evil,
but they can help us eat better, know more, and make room for learning.
The self and site
assessments are extra credit so don't forget to send them also if you choose.
I do not return the last
assignment "Smith4" but I do explain the points received, any extra
credit points, and the points accumulated for the quarter.
Write the world view in the first person. Do not slip into
the second person. Keep the self assessment within the perspective of
"Beginning Thoughts" that you read at the very first of the quarter.